There have been two or three high profile cases of people who have gone to Switzerland to have assisted suicides. Every time this comes into the spotlight, there are calls from the suicide lobby to legalise the practice in some form. Whilst acknowledging that there are alot of very ill people who would wish to die to relieve their suffering, and also the suffering of their relatives, I always feel uncomfortable about the idea of it being legalised in general. I believe it is the start of a slippery slope where people could be assisted to kill themselves when they haven't explored all the alternatives. I think that each individual case should be judged on it's own merits, rather than passing some sort of general law.
For example the recent case of the Rugby player Daniel James aged 23, a gifted player who had a career in front of him, who suffered permanent paralysis from the chest downwards after his spine became collapsed in a scrum. He went to the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland to have an assisted suicide, supported by his family, because he didn't want to live a 'second class existence'. There are two things which bother me about this. Firstly his very young age; surely he had alot of time to explore options such as learning to live a meaningul life with his disability, and secondly, it was barely 18 months between the accident and him committing suicide, surely not enough time to give himself chance to come to terms with the tragic accident. Just in passing I know a friend who has been paralyzed from the chest downwards for many years; he used to be a pilot for the RAF before he had a motorbike accident which put an end to all of that. Despite his disability, and having alot of reliance on others, and sometimes being in alot of pain, he is a very confident and happy person. His way of dealing with it was that he is a buddhist and after the accident decided to become a buddhist monk, living in a buddhist community and helping the community to thrive. That is how he channeled his energy into an alternative lifestyle. Surely someone else in a similar situation such as Daniel James, whilst not having a spiritual outlet, needs to fully explore all the options. Perhaps the best solution is a big change in the mental outlook, not to rush and kill oneself.
The first link below is a news article about Daniel James, the second is a link about Dignitas.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/hereford/worcs/7675745.stm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dignitas_(euthanasia_group)